What Biofuel Producers Need to Substantiate Lower-Carbon Feedstocks

How much more would you pay for corn with a lower carbon intensity score? The score gives you a place to start, but before paying a premium, you need to know whether the records support the score, and the numbers work for your plant.

The first question may be whether the available records can be connected and substantiated well enough to support the claim.

A grower may have records of farming practices while an elevator holds purchasing and delivery information. Before asking a supplier to collect more information, determine whether the evidence already available can be connected to support the opportunity.

Look at what is already there

A provisional CI score tells you where to look. The records help you decide whether to buy.

The gap between a provisional score and a substantiated claim may be narrower than it appears. For many corn farms, existing satellite-derived and agronomic data may provide much of the information needed to identify promising lower-CI opportunities.

In a DTNsights conversation on renewable fuels, Courtney Yuskis, DTN’s commercial leader for sustainability, explained that estimated carbon intensity scores can help buyers identify potential feedstock suppliers, while farm records and farmer attestations support those estimates.

That makes the provisional score a screening tool, not the claim itself. It tells you where to look more closely; the available evidence then helps determine whether the opportunity is worth pursuing.

Some records may be missing. Others may sit in separate systems, use different identifiers, or lack a clear connection to the crop being purchased. Those situations call for different responses.

Consider an ethanol producer comparing two corn suppliers with similar prices and delivery terms. One offers a modest potential CI benefit with well-organized records. The other appears to offer a larger benefit, but the supporting information is scattered across farm, supplier, and delivery records. Neither has completed verification.

The second supplier should not necessarily be ruled out because its documentation is harder to use. If the information can be connected and substantiated at a reasonable cost, the larger potential benefit may justify the additional work. If it cannot, the first supplier may be the better choice. The point is to understand the gap before deciding what the opportunity is worth.

The CI score behind a California LCFS claim and a 45Z claim are not the same number. They are calculated under separate frameworks, and a strong result in one program does not translate directly to the other. A producer comparing suppliers across compliance contexts should confirm which methodology applies before concluding what the score means.

Think beyond one supplier

Solving the documentation gap for one supplier can make an individual purchase worthwhile. Building a process for connecting and substantiating information across suppliers can make lower-CI sourcing a scalable procurement capability rather than a series of one-off projects.

That means linking CI data to the systems that already manage grain receipts, contracts, and inventory. Keeping it in a separate workflow means rebuilding the same reconciliation each time a new supplier relationship begins. Each claim would still need its own supporting evidence and any required verification, but the process of bringing those records together would not have to start over each time.

Follow the information through the business

USDA’s guidelines require the Biofuel Feedstock Report to pass through the supply chain to the biofuel refiner, and its final rule requires CI claims to follow the physical grain through mass-balance accounting. For producers, that means substantiation cannot stop at the farm or supplier. The supporting information must remain connected to the commodity as it moves through receiving, inventory, and reporting.

A well-documented purchase can still leave work downstream if the agricultural information does not connect with those later records. Looking only at supplier readiness could miss that part of the cost.

For producers evaluating an investment, a useful question is how much reconciliation the business will still need after the information has been collected. Where will someone have to match records manually? Which connections will need to be rebuilt for reporting? Can the people reviewing the claim follow the supporting information through the applicable accounting process?

Those questions help distinguish storing documentation from maintaining the connections among the farm, supplier, and transaction records needed to support a claim. Both matter, but they solve different problems. Neither replaces independent verification where it is required.

Keep the plant economics in view

The potential benefit still must make sense for the plant. Feedstock CI contributes to the final fuel emissions profile alongside the rest of the production system. In its July analysis of potential 45Z value, the University of Illinois showed how modeled values changed with assumptions about those other emissions.

The commercial calculation includes the potential additional value, the cost of substantiating it, and the uncertainty that remains.

A lower provisional feedstock score therefore gives a producer something to investigate, rather than a complete answer about what to pay. The commercial calculation includes the potential additional value, the cost of substantiating it, and the remaining uncertainty. Connecting existing information may improve that calculation. It may also reveal that an opportunity does not justify further spending. Either finding helps the producer make a more informed choice.

What would you pay for lower-CI corn? Part of the answer may depend on how readily you can substantiate the information behind it.

Before passing over a promising supplier, determine what kind of gap you have: Is evidence missing? Does it exist but needs to be connected across records? Or does it simply need farmer confirmation or other required verification?

Knowing which gap you are solving helps determine the work required, who needs to do it, and what the opportunity is ultimately worth.

Grey Montgomery

About the Author

Grey Montgomery, General Manager of Agriculture at DTN, brings more than 25 years of leadership experience in technology, innovation, and agribusiness. He oversees DTN’s agriculture solutions, delivering agronomic insights, market intelligence, sustainability data, and award-winning news to farmers and agribusinesses.